watching the olympics: yes or no?

Back in March I raised the question of whether or not the readers of this blog will be watching the Beijing Olympics this summer. The games begin in just a few weeks, and I’d like to raise the question once again.

In March I began thinking about the Olympics because of the Chinese government’s violent reaction to the protests in Tibet. Last week I began thinking again about whether or not I’ll watch the games after reading a Washington Post story about the recent crackdown on Chinese dissidents by the government. Reporter Jill Drew writes about the toll this harassment has had one one of those dissidents, Huang Qi,

Huang, 45, is among dozens of Chinese writers and lawyers who have been convicted, detained, placed under house arrest, tailed or otherwise harassed as part of China’s broad crackdown on dissent in the run-up to the Olympic Games in Beijing next month. At least 44 writers are in Chinese prisons in violation of their rights to free expression, more than at the beginning of the year, according to a report released Tuesday by the PEN American Center, an advocacy group.

While much has been written about the political stakes involved, less well known is the personal toll that opposing the official Chinese government line these days can take. Huang’s friends are often harassed and sometimes detained; his wife, Zeng Li, has been forced to change apartments frequently after police pressed landlords to evict her; frequent beatings when he was in prison left Huang with brain injuries that now spark bouts of violent anger and other health problems. The stress eventually became too much for Zeng; she separated from Huang in 2006.

Time Magazine’s Simon Elegant offers this commentary on China’s promise to increase human rights when they won the right to host the games.

And what about the human rights and general openness that were supposed to have been enhanced by the awarding of the Games? It hardly needs to be said that the exact opposite happened and most dissenting voices have either been jailed or intimidated into silence. Same goes for the promised greater media freedom… My feeling is that the conservative forces in the top leadership (or hardliners if you prefer) will be emboldened by the fact that despite a severe crackdown in the full glare of pre-Olympics publicity, there has been virtually no substantive international reaction. I’d wager that they’ll argue that there’s no reason not to keep those irritating dissidents in jail if there’s no downside. It could even encourage security forces to tighten further once the Games are over.

Given all of this, I find the Associated Press’ report of 10,000 free Bibles being distributed in the Olympic Village to be little more than political pandering. (via CT)

Here is the question: As an American Christian, what is an appropriate response to what is currently happening in China? I’m interested in what you think about the individual’s response. Let’s leave the question of our government’s action out of it for now (though both presidential candidates have opinions: McCain and Obama). I know some see no connection between the Olympics and the politics of any country, including the host country. Others will see economics and politics every time they tune in. Is deciding to not watch the games a small act of solidarity with those Chinese citizens who have suffered as a result of the Games? Or, would a decision to avoid the Olympics only hurt the (mostly) amateur athletes who have worked so hard to make it to Beijing?

11 responses to “watching the olympics: yes or no?”

  1. We should watch and cheer for our countries and our athletes. If we boycotted stuff from every country that opresses humans we would not have much of anything. Let see, Canada (2010 Olympic hosts) and the USA (1996 hosts) relegate Native Americans to reservations. Chicago, during the 50s and 60s, developed huge public housing tracts to concentrate the black population in select areas so Mayor Daley (Sr.) could enjoy their democratic vote. We should not take oil from any Middle Eastern nation because of the way women are oppressed. We should not accept any products from India (including on-line and over the phone technical assistance) because of their caste system. No more Spanish products (Barcelona hosted the Olympics) because of their treatment of the Basques. No more Greek products (2004 hosts) because of their treatment of Turks and Macedonians. No more Israeli products because of their oppression of the Palestinians. No more English products (2012 Olympic hosts) because they won’t return Northern Ireland to the Irish and they take all the oil from the Scottish North Sea. Australia (2000? hosts) don’t treat the Aborigines with great respect. So we shouldn’t eat any more vegemite. I’m just going to forget about African nations. Russia…nope. They had the audacity to invade Afghanistan in 1979. We have to boycott caviar and vodka.

    What country is okay? Perhaps we can enjoy some Norwegian products or other Scandanavian products. The Swiss are always neutral, I’ll eat their chocolate. I think we can enjoy some geothermal heat from Iceland. New Zealand is okay, I think. They have high regard for their native people (begins with an “M” but I can’t remember the name).

    We are a world of sinners. We are a world of oppressors. None of us deserves to host an olympic event. We are stuck with Olympics in China. This is entirely thanks to the Olympic committee, which I’m sure would never accept bribes or kick backs for their vote. That whole system is corrupt. The corrupt system chose a corrupt country and they might next choose a corrupt Chicago.

    Should I remember that the Olympics are on, I will watch.

  2. I’ll end up watching some. For me, the political stuff is far away from sport. In fact, sport is supposed to be (at least for the olympics) some sort of “let’s throw away all the other stuff and just compete” thing.

    And for that reason only, I love the olympics. I’m sad that politics is even in the equation, frankly. I understand why people would boycott, but honestly, it seems pointless.

    The only people getting the bad end of the stick when that happens is NBC. Which, sure I can see hatin’ on, but seriously? What is your not watching going to do for China or not do for China? Not a heck of a lot.

    I’d rather just see people who are masters of techniques they’ve worked on since they could walk vie for gold. That sounds much more fun and interesting than “how can I make a statement”.

    Personally, I think it’s a matter of getting over ourselves. I would boycott ATTENDING the olympics. That I could understand.

    But watching them on television? I see absolutely no harm. In fact, I see more harm in boycotting watching it than anything else.

  3. Now I’ll answer the question in bold: what is a Christian’s response to what’s happening in China? Prayer and missionary support. But, just to stir the pot, what’s a Chinese Christian’s response to what’s happening in the Americas? Prayer and missionary support? Or would a boycott of the 2010 Winter Olympics help cause the Canadian gov’t to improve conditions on reservations so that the teen suicide rate would drop, so they wouldn’t be drinking antifreeze and sniffing glue?

    We’re all so depraved and of the depraved, I’m certainly one. Prayer and missionary support. But who takes the time to think of or pray for China? I certainly don’t. I’ve got my family, co-workers, pastors, friends, neighbors, churches, missionaries, prayer chain requests, my own sin, etc. Oh yeah God, please free Tibet and stop the Chinese government from oppressing its citizens.
    You know what’s really convicting, I’ve spent more time writing on this blog in the last two days than I have praying. Good bye.

  4. I won’t be watching, but that’s because of a different boycott altogether – we don’t have TV reception. (gasp!)

    If I did, I’m sure I would watch them a bit. China certainly has their share of cultural problems, but we feed into them every single day with our purchasing decisions among others. Not to mention the enormous abuses our own culture is heavily tainted with. Not to say that the enormity of the problem suggests that we do less, but I’d rather we watch the Olympics and be finding ways to change our lifestyles in ways that would really make a difference in the ethics of our Global world. Before I boycotted their Olympics I’d want to spend some time trying to remove the enormous plank in our own culture-eye.

  5. After seeing the report that the United States is holding a 16-year old child at Guantanamo Bay, in direct violation of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child I am thinking about boycotting all US sporting events. MLB, NBA, NFL, PGA, etc. Although maybe I don’t have to because the US never signed the convention (joining only Somalia in not affirming the protection of children). When it comes to human rights violations, I guess I’m going to have to agree with Keith and say that its going to be pretty hard to find a nation that hasn’t violated someone’s human rights.

    That said, what to do about it? The issues seem a whole lot bigger than you or I. As far as boycotting viewing the Olympics goes I doubt it would have much effect. Unless such a critical mass of people partook in the boycott that it got the news media’s attention somehow. I think it comes down to each of us trying to make a difference in our sphere’s of influence, and being sensitive to the possibility of our sphere’s being expanded. Perhaps we’ve never thought twice about human rights in China – but maybe we should start.

  6. I’ve always been a mediocre Olympics-watcher- I pick and choose the events I like best and skip the rest. I don’t see how my tv-viewing has ever sent to a message to the host countries in the past and I fail to see how it would affect China now. We need to support the athletes that have trained so hard for this moment. There are other ways to get the point across. I agreed with much of Keith’s first comment. There is no perfect country, not even the US (shocker that it is.) Maybe we need to boycot the Olympic committee?

  7. First, thanks for the comments. I posted these questions because I’m genuinely interested in what you folks think about these kinds of things. Your thoughts help me see issues (like the Olympics) in a larger context. Thanks.

    Secondly, many of the comments lead me to believe that we should not abstain from watching the Olympics because it won’t make a difference on the ground in China. I absolutely agree. My question about not watching the Games has little to do with affecting change and more to do with a Christian response. While such a response may lead to visible change, it may not. As Christians do we only do or not do those things that lead to immediate results? Certainly there are practices and disciplines associated with our faith- prayer and fasting come to mind- that may or may not lead to visible change.

    At certain times throughout history Christians have chosen to avoid certain cultural activities not because they thought they could stop those activities but because they believed it would be un-Christian for them to be associated with them. The imperial games is an ancient example. More recently, as stores stayed open on Sundays, some Christians chose not to shop on the sabbath, believing all deserved a day of rest.

    Again, I welcome your comments. I guess I’m coming at this less from a “let’s change the world” perspective than I am simply wondering if our discipleship to Christ compels us to participate counter culturally with something like the Olympics.

  8. I don’t support a boycott and I want the Beijing Olympics to be a success.
    But the Games are a chance, while the world is watching, to press China for change.

    Without change China will carry on executing more of its citizens than any other country in the world, it will continue censoring the media and the Internet and it will continue locking up and torturing those who try to stand up for their rights and the rights of others.

    It isn’t political. To stand up for human rights is to stand up for the values enshrined in the Olympic Charter.

    http://www.uncensor.com.au

  9. There are a couple perspectives to your points about boycotting not to change the world but as a response to our culture. You list fasting and prayer as something we do that doesn’t always lead to visible change. Then you list other things that we Christians have avoided in culture. Regarding fasting and prayer…you don’t always do it to change the world but rather to change yourself. Also, it draws you closer to God. If boycotting the olympics draws you closer to God, go for it.
    For cultural…we Christians have avoided Sunday shopping, movies, certain music, etc. because they were (perceived as) sin. While China’s actions may be full of sin, the Olympics are sports, not sins. I think someone above pointed out that a boycott on Chinese products would be more effective than not watching the Olympics.

  10. Hello David and Maggie,
    If you will entertain some words from an older fat guy; first fasting in me has always led to visible change only sometimes spiritual change .
    In regard to any boycott – 1.) it is useless unless the party boycotted nows by letter and demonstration they are being boycotted.
    2.) it does a good job of letting others know what we are opposed to – this is a neutral thing. If we are only known for what we are opposed to we have failed miserably as witnesses for Christ.
    3.) I remember but can’t site the story of a Christian man who in the third century (give or take a few years) jumped to the arena floor horrified and crying out against the gladitorial blood shed. He was murdered by the ones he was trying to save (hmmm). It was said to have emptied the arena and that attendance fell rapidly thereafter across the empire. Was that a boycott or was it “one laying down his life for another?”
    4.) my vote – let’s become known for Who we stand for and only in that Light be known for what we are against.
    Good to see pictures of you and Maggie. When you are in western NC again try to let us know. We would be blessed to see you.
    In Christ
    Dennis McCutcheon
    Director
    MedEquip Missions, a ministry of HIM
    573 Fairview Road
    Asheville, NC 28803

  11. Dennis- really good to hear from you. We were in Portland recently and kept commenting on how much it reminded us of western NC. Don’t take it for granted man! You live in a beautiful spot.

    I appreciate your point that Christians must be known for what we are for not simply what we’re against. In this case I think that would mean being for those who experience any type of oppression due to the Olympics.

Leave a comment