happy saturday: wall*e

Friend and blogger Jason Dye think Wall*E ought to be considered for the Best Picture award by the Academy, rather than the Animated Feature Film award it is in contention for.  He makes a good case.

It seems that the only type of genre that the Academy respects is drama. That is too bad. However, I think it’s also rather odd that a group of professional movie-makers seems to think that the medium (actually, media) of animation is a sort of genre itself. And I suppose that argument could also be made for feature-length documentaries (some of the most phenomenal movies made in the last twenty years are docs) and foreign language films, but those people have their own films to sell you on, I’ve got this one: Wall*E.


Wall*E is a story of a solitary but optimistic robot left with the futile task of cleaning up the Earth’s garbage long after humans have left the planet as a huge, inhabitable dumping ground (in fact, the only other creature on the planet from our perspective is a cockroach that acts as his sidekick). Wall*E’s loneliness is interrupted by a high-tech scout robot named Eve. The ever-playful Wall*E – a true hopeless romantic and hapless put-upon in the tradition of the Silent-era greats Buster Keaton and Charlie Chapman – fawns over and tries to woo Eve. The ever-secretive Eve begins to lay her guard down due to the powerful effect of his charm, openness and the fact that he makes her laugh (single men, take note). Alas, Eve suddenly turns silent and awaits the return of her shuttle after discovering a plant that Wall*E’s been holding in his salvage pad. We later learn that this is her primary objective, to scope out the planet for signs of life (Hmmm…) to bring back to her ship, the Axiom – which holds the descendants of those who abandoned Earth seven hundred years earlier.

Critics of the film tend to say that once the movie leaves Earth and heads off into the reaches of space (when Wall*E tags along with the shuttle) it loses steam and identity – or even worse, it becomes a preachy film. Rather, I suggest, the theme sharpens in exploration and with tension. It is on the Axiom that Wall*E discovers a world full of people who have lost their moorings, who have no True North, who are adrift at sea in virtually every possible manner. It is through Wall*E’s spirit of kindness and his identity rooted in love and resulting self-sacrifice that others are gathered around him. If his cause moves from a futile And it is through his identity, purpose and actions that they begin to renew their cause and their identity. In fact, the one villain of the movie is the one machine that cannot see past its old objective to a new, relevant, and meaningful one. Everyone else essentially adopt the Captain’s protest, “I don’t want to survive; I want to live.”

As per the technical stuff, this being a Pixar movie, and helmed by Finding Nemo‘s director Andrew Stanton, it almost goes without saying that the film is breathtakingly beautiful and a wonder to look at. I feel like a child looking at a whole new world most times I enter a Pixar presentation. Initially I was disappointed in the feature’s brevity (98 mins.), but upon subsequent viewings, I found its economy to be refreshing, allowing me – like some of my favorite albums – a chance to draw from the well time and again without subsequent exhaustion. And, as with all great comedy – and, for that matter, drama – timing is everything and the timing here seems appropriate, if not slowed down during bits. It’s too bad it didn’t come out at a time when it would have been appreciated by a more open-minded Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences.

12 thoughts on “happy saturday: wall*e”

  1. I’m going to have to watch this one again. When it came out, the Wall Street Journal’s review was consistent with yours…Best Picture worthy. I went with the family during the summer and I left empty. It was nice but I didn’t think it was great. I’ve read your review and others to which you have linked. I think I’m missing something (it’s not you, it’s me). I think my wife bought the movie at Christmas. Perhaps we will watch it tonight (Happy Valentines Day!). I’ll keep an open mind and provide my re-review in the morn.

  2. geepers. Dave, thanks for posting this long-winded and confusing bit of rhetoric. i must wish i had the talent of Kerouac!

    i would definitely recommend Ratatouille, although for different reasons. Ratatouille, i believe, is about looking for finding talent and beauty in the unlikeliest of places and people. it’s also about striving for excellence.

    but then again, i tend to promote Pixar movies over nearly every other hollywood movies.

  3. I’m so shallow. I like ratatouille because it’s funny and I like to cook. I never considered the deeper points that you’ve identified…but, upon consideration, you’re right.
    I’m the sort of person on American Bandstand who says, “It has a nice beat and you can dance to it. I give it an 8 out of 10, Dick.”

  4. oh, and when i say “x movie is about”, i really mean, “i saw these themes in this movie and i’m arrogant enough to tell you that that overrides everything else.” hope that clarifies…

  5. I definitely agree that this was one of the most obvious snubs of the year. Wall*E dared to be the first mainstream industry film to have enough faith in its storytelling to give us what amounts to a silent film for a large portion og its running time. It’s a gutsy movie, but The Academy settles for sure bets like Frost/Nixon because Howard’s name is behind it even though they know it has no right whatsoever to be up for best pic.

    This is yet another year that the Oscar’s reveal their cultural lag by playing it safe with conventional choices.

  6. Coming from an entertainment background…do the Oscars REALLY matter anymore? Did they ever, really matter? People see what they like. Some stuff gets awards. Some stuff is appropriate, and there’s always the head-scratching on some nominations.

    Wall-E was brilliant. I loved it, and thought it was so intelligent and cute and funny throughout. Who cares if it gets “the right” award? It got made! It got seen! That’s what’s important!

  7. Sorry David… I’m not trying to always be contrarian here… I promise. 🙂

    I just don’t tend to comment unless I feel strongly one way or the other. Sorry!

  8. Apparently Wall*E is on sale at Target this week for $10. Perhaps we’ll buy it and I can provide my review. I can do a two-fer. Wall*E and Ratatouille. You’ll be startled at how shallow and uninformed I can be (if you haven’t already figured that out from my previous posts).

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s